Wednesday, September 8, 2010

The Wrong Lesson: Teaching College Reporters to be Meek

In “The Wrong Lesson: Teaching College Reporters to be Meek” by David Wallis, Wallis describes how authority figures in college are able to control who and what the school newspapers can put on in their articles. Wallis uses a few examples on how someone with high authority in college is able to control what the school publishes in their newspapers. One example that Wallis uses describes how “A college freshmen found information and story that was involving the school chancellor. When the college freshmen looked up all the information, research everything that he could about the chancellor the student was ready to meet to the chancellor and talk to him about his research. When the college freshmen got back to his editor, the freshmen quit and said that the chancellor had threatened him about his financial aid and the chancellor made the freshmen rethink about his decision on the article. The freshmen then quit the paper.” The chancellor was able to change the freshmen’s mind about the article because he was able to manipulate the student by threatening him by taking away his financial aid.

The article describes how important figures in college can influence what the college can publish. The beginning of the article didn’t catch my attention, it started with a story, but it doesn’t explain his reason. The article has good examples about how college officials are influential and has the final say in anything that involves the school in any way. The article doesn’t show which side that Wallis is on. He had the examples but he didn’t elaborate on them, he would describe what happened but he didn’t show reasoning why he had used this as an example. In the end of the article I get lost about what he is talking about he goes from talking about the schools administration and then starts describing that “Parents should not let their child go to schools that censor their students.” The article was okay, if Wallis was to elaborate his views it would have been a better essay.

No comments:

Post a Comment