Wednesday, November 3, 2010

Dolly's False Legacy

In the essay “Dolly’s False Legacy” by Ian Wilmut, Wilmut describes the difference between having a child and having a child cloned.  There are a lot of reasons that someone would have a clone of someone who they miss or passed away.  The person who wants a clone would want to see the person that was really important to their life.  The essay describes the positives and negatives of cloning someone. 

A positive for someone to be able to clone someone is to be able to see someone who passed away.  The person who is cloning another person is because that person wants to have that person back in their life even if that person is starting over as a baby/child.  Another positive is to be able to raise the clone in a different and the child would be different when growing up.  If the child was really good at sports when they come back, they would be good at sports or if the person that wants the child to be different the child could do something new and see what the difference it could be if life were to be different.   

A negative for doing this is if you clone someone would it be weird for that person to see an image of themselves back when they were younger.  Would the clone be an exact replica of the person or would the child be a lot different from the rest of everyone else.  A negative would be someone would be able to see the negatives of their life and be able to change their past and make it a positive or negative.  The clone would be able to do things that that person wishes that they could do.

Having a clone would be fun to do because that means that someone else would have to do other things.  In another way the child would be able to have different opportunities and you could see what the options are and be able to see the positive and negatives.  That person would be able to see what would be the right thing to do and what not to do. 

Cloning has its limits but in the end cloning should not happen.  If it happens, then life would be different and everything would change.  We would be able to change the things that have been done wrong but making mistakes is what makes us (people) what they really are. 

Thursday, October 21, 2010

Race in America. "We Would Like to Believe We are over the Problem"

In the essay "Race in America. "We Would Like to Believe We are over the Problem" by Maryann Cusimano Love, Love questions if the United States is ready for an African American President.  In the beginning of the essay, she brings up President Barack Obama during his candidacy.  Love brings up the point was the United States ready to have an African American run the country. 
In the essay, Love brings in good information like “African-Americans like Senator Obama; we would like to believe we “are over” the race problem.  That is something that might never go away.  In the essay, Love puts some statistics like “African-Americans have lower life expectancies than white Americans by six or seven years.  Twenty-five percent of black Americans live in poverty.  One-third of African-American children live in poverty.  Black poverty rates are triple those of white” (Love 450).  These quotes are not about the race problem.  These are just examples of how people in our society are being affected.
Also in the article, “Delegate Hargrove’s suggestion that we “get over” the past by not bringing it up can be tempting because it is easy.  Senator Obama’s vision of post-racial politics is inviting because it is hopeful.  Be we are not there yet, and the only way to get there is to work through the present-day ramifications of our persistent past, not only as individuals (“I don’t condone racism”) but as communities (What are we doing to end unacceptable racial inequities?[“])” (Love 451). The argument for the essay is that in society, we need change.  It is not going to take just one person to help complete this obstacle.  President Obama is the one who is going to start to accomplish this goal, but everyone in the country has to do their part to make sure this obstacle will be completed.

Tuesday, October 12, 2010

How People Turn Monstrous

In the essay “How People Turn Monstrous,” by Mark Buchanan, it describes are people really monsters when certain things happen or are they really that type of person.  The essay described how Sgt. Ivan Frederick II, was found guilty of “assault, conspiracy, dereliction of duty and maltreatment of detainees, and he is halfway through his eight-year prison sentence.” This is about how he was charged for these things and to see if he did these things as a way to show that he can be like everyone else or he is that type of person.  Which brings up the question “Can someone be guilty just for acting like most ordinary human beings?” (Buchanan 384)

There have been tests to see if it pressure from every around the environment are like guilty of assault or conspiracy or if this is just for that person to just fit in.  The example of this experiment was by Stanford University and was conducted in the 1970s.  The psychology department had the students play the guards and inmates and the setting was in the basement of the psychology department.   The experiment resulted with the “guards becoming more abusive, and in 36 hours the first prisoner had an emotional breakdown, crying and screaming.  The researchers had to stop the experiment after six days.  Even normal kids who were professed pacifists were acting sadistically, taking pleasure in inflicting cruel punishments on people they knew were to be completely blameless” (Buchanan 384).

This quote describes how the students who were chosen to be an example of what could happen to the guards and inmates.  The students that were just normal and didn’t do anything out of the ordinary started to abuse the inmates and inflict pain and punishment.  That when Sgt. Frederick entered the Abu Ghraib prison, he had perfect marks and has not committed anything wrong.  He described that when he went into the prison, he saw the guards before him doing the things that he was caught for.  This shows that the person who was or is in charge would not take the blame and made someone else suffer for it. 

An example in today’s society would be when a class is taking a test and how there are many of the students having wandering eyes to see what the answers are.  That in the end, there is usually one person that gets caught.  When that person gets caught he/she and the person that was probably helping would be in trouble and have to pay the punishments, but the other people that did this won’t get in trouble because they are the ones who believe they are of the high class and it doesn’t involve them, so they should not be punished for what is happening around them. 

In society everyone is not usually bad.  People are changed by surroundings and by the people they are around and influence them.  When there is someone being made fun, people would just watch and no one would get into the argument and stop what is happening.  People are not monsters but people can turn monstrous by the people that influence them. 

Monday, September 27, 2010

Response "Our Tired, Our Poor, Our Kids"

There are over hundreds of families with children that are homeless. Children’s lives are get destroyed everyday because the child does not have a home/place that the child could go to after school.  While wealthy/middle class families have their own house.  The family has their own room.  While other families around America live in one bedroom and the families have to share a bathroom with two or three other families. 

“Twenty Years ago New York City provided emergency shelter for just under a thousand families a day; last month it had to find spaces for 10,000 children on a given night.  Not since the Great Depression have this many babies, toddlers, and kids had no place like home” (Quindlen 358).  This essay was written on March 12, 2001.  This could mean that children without homes may have increased and there are more children that are living in shelters or on the streets.  There are families all over the nation that have been evicted from their homes, families that do not have money because the parents are recovering drunk or drug addicts. These families are not able to pay their rent and now the children have to suffer by living in a shelter or on the streets.  The foster system has tried to get the children into the foster program where the child could go to a new family or the child would go and stay with family. 

“Today the average homeless woman is younger than ever before, may have been in foster care or in shelters herself and so considers a chaotic childhood the norm.  Many never finished high school and have never held a job” (Quindlen 359).  This is a scary thing to hear about because it means that if a girl is put into foster care or has been in a shelter that means that would make the girl/women feel like that is a way someone is supposed to live.  Their life would be different which means that the person might not finish high school and would not be able to hold down a job. 

“People don’t like to hear it, but shelters are going to be the low-income housing of the future” (Quindlen 359).  Families that are not close to each other could be a cause for families to separate. Shelter will become the new housing because the more people that are homeless will live on the streets or have to stay in shelters.  Children are not able to live the experience like other children.  While some kids get their own bed and get as many toys as they want, some families have to share a bed with two or three kids and the kids are not able to get new toys, the children have to play with the toys that they have received since they were young. 

Children living on the street will never experience living in a house because the family is living on the street or in a shelter.  The parents are not the ones that are suffering, because the child will never experience what it would be like to live in a house.  Families that have to live like this is sad to hear and see.  Families with children will suffer more than children on the streets because the experience will be different for families and for children living on the street.

Wednesday, September 8, 2010

The Wrong Lesson: Teaching College Reporters to be Meek

In “The Wrong Lesson: Teaching College Reporters to be Meek” by David Wallis, Wallis describes how authority figures in college are able to control who and what the school newspapers can put on in their articles. Wallis uses a few examples on how someone with high authority in college is able to control what the school publishes in their newspapers. One example that Wallis uses describes how “A college freshmen found information and story that was involving the school chancellor. When the college freshmen looked up all the information, research everything that he could about the chancellor the student was ready to meet to the chancellor and talk to him about his research. When the college freshmen got back to his editor, the freshmen quit and said that the chancellor had threatened him about his financial aid and the chancellor made the freshmen rethink about his decision on the article. The freshmen then quit the paper.” The chancellor was able to change the freshmen’s mind about the article because he was able to manipulate the student by threatening him by taking away his financial aid.

The article describes how important figures in college can influence what the college can publish. The beginning of the article didn’t catch my attention, it started with a story, but it doesn’t explain his reason. The article has good examples about how college officials are influential and has the final say in anything that involves the school in any way. The article doesn’t show which side that Wallis is on. He had the examples but he didn’t elaborate on them, he would describe what happened but he didn’t show reasoning why he had used this as an example. In the end of the article I get lost about what he is talking about he goes from talking about the schools administration and then starts describing that “Parents should not let their child go to schools that censor their students.” The article was okay, if Wallis was to elaborate his views it would have been a better essay.