In the essay “How People Turn Monstrous,” by Mark Buchanan, it describes are people really monsters when certain things happen or are they really that type of person. The essay described how Sgt. Ivan Frederick II, was found guilty of “assault, conspiracy, dereliction of duty and maltreatment of detainees, and he is halfway through his eight-year prison sentence.” This is about how he was charged for these things and to see if he did these things as a way to show that he can be like everyone else or he is that type of person. Which brings up the question “Can someone be guilty just for acting like most ordinary human beings?” (Buchanan 384)
There have been tests to see if it pressure from every around the environment are like guilty of assault or conspiracy or if this is just for that person to just fit in. The example of this experiment was by Stanford University and was conducted in the 1970s. The psychology department had the students play the guards and inmates and the setting was in the basement of the psychology department. The experiment resulted with the “guards becoming more abusive, and in 36 hours the first prisoner had an emotional breakdown, crying and screaming. The researchers had to stop the experiment after six days. Even normal kids who were professed pacifists were acting sadistically, taking pleasure in inflicting cruel punishments on people they knew were to be completely blameless” (Buchanan 384).
This quote describes how the students who were chosen to be an example of what could happen to the guards and inmates. The students that were just normal and didn’t do anything out of the ordinary started to abuse the inmates and inflict pain and punishment. That when Sgt. Frederick entered the Abu Ghraib prison, he had perfect marks and has not committed anything wrong. He described that when he went into the prison, he saw the guards before him doing the things that he was caught for. This shows that the person who was or is in charge would not take the blame and made someone else suffer for it.
An example in today’s society would be when a class is taking a test and how there are many of the students having wandering eyes to see what the answers are. That in the end, there is usually one person that gets caught. When that person gets caught he/she and the person that was probably helping would be in trouble and have to pay the punishments, but the other people that did this won’t get in trouble because they are the ones who believe they are of the high class and it doesn’t involve them, so they should not be punished for what is happening around them.
In society everyone is not usually bad. People are changed by surroundings and by the people they are around and influence them. When there is someone being made fun, people would just watch and no one would get into the argument and stop what is happening. People are not monsters but people can turn monstrous by the people that influence them.
No comments:
Post a Comment